MR. HOLMES IS NOT EXACTLY WHO CONAN DOYLE WROTE ABOUT
Conan Doyle’s novels have been made into excellent films, so how can Sherlock Holmes appear in another movie? The answer is Mr. Holmes, directed by Bill Condon and based on a novel by Mitch Cullin, which depicts a retired 90-year-old Holmes (played by Ian McKellen) in Sussex living with a housekeeper Mrs. Munro (Laura Linney) and her precocious son Roger (Milo Parker) in 1947. According to the pseudo-biopic, Doyle was trying to depict the real Holmes and made up the pipe, deerstalker cap, and various mystery plots; filmviewers are also led to believe that Dr. Watson has already passed on. Most of the action in Mr. Holmes revolves around the relationship between tottering Holmes and eager-to-learn Roger. When Holmes introduces Roger to bee farming, he finds a mystery—that many bees are dying from an unknown cause. Roger wants to solve the mystery, but runs into trouble until Holmes solves the puzzle. Meanwhile, there is flashback to a male client whose wife is acting strangely—that is, until Holmes stalks her and is able to report a simple explanation. And a subplot involves a short trip to Japan to collect an important herb, perhaps a final delicacy to enjoy as his life slips away. However, audiences who may expect a fascinating crime story, a “Great Scott!” insight, and a “not a moment to lose“ dash to prevent an untimely death will find the film unsatisfactory. MH